Home

NYC Sculpture
Profiles: Cont. Sculptors
Essays
Gifts, Greetings
Site Updates
FAQ
Contact
About the Site
Battery Pk Podcast
Links
Blog

Most comprehensive guidebook in print to outdoor sculpture in Manhattan

more info - order

 

Outdoor Monuments of Manhattan, Essay 4

Continents (at the U.S. Customs House)

By Daniel Chester French, dedicated 1907

Bibliography, Out-takes, Discussion Questions,
Suggested Readings

 

Dedication and comments on the sculpture

Note #1: In researching Outdoor Monuments of Manhattan: A Historical Guide, I often relied on contemporary accounts in periodicals to clarify details of sculptures that have since become obscure. I find such descriptions fascinating in themselves (what did the reporter notice and consider worth commenting on?), and have therefore included several lengthy descriptions of the Continents below, in chronological order, with comments occasionally inserted in square brackets. Close-up photos show details mentioned in these descriptions.

Note #2: the New York Times online is indexed erratically for these sculptures. The most effective search seems to be "Custom House Cass Gilbert."

 An article in the New York Times variously cited as 1/17/1904, 1/27/1904 or 1/17/1917 is supposed to quote French on the meaning of the sculptures, but I've been unable to locate it on the Times online.

 New York Times  4/30/1905: "For Four Marble Groups. Symbols of Continents for the Custom House by D.C. French Shown" was written after a reception at French's studio to display the finished clay models. Some details of the design were subsequently changed, as is clear from the models preserved at Chesterwood and the correspondence recorded in Richman (Daniel Chester French, An American Sculptor, pp. 103-111). America is described thus: "The young woman with alert face, raised eyebrows, and a flaming torch in her hand carries on her lap a sheaf of maize stalks with the ripe ears of corn. On the side and front of her throne are hieroglyphs hinting at the Mexican inscriptions. By her side kneels a partially draped man guiding a winged wheel before him on the ground.

At her back, with plumed head close to her ear, kneels an Indian chief. As one ascends the stair to the main entrance this group will be on the left, with the crouching figure of Invention [this is the only source to call the figure "Invention"] near at hand. Just behind the youth is a group of attributes - architecture, literature, painting, &c. - giving by their mass a pyramidal outline to the group when seen from this side." [The finished marbles don't have these attributes, they have Native American pottery and a totem pole.]

Here's Europe: "To the right hand as one mounts the stairs will sit on a Greek throne, having riders from the Parthenon in low relief on its base, the draped figure of Europe. She rests her left arm on a big, old-fashioned book, and this in turn rests on a big globe of the earth. Behind is a figure with drapery over the head, pondering upon a skull - like the grave digger in 'Hamlet.' On the back of the throne is an eagle with spread wings and thunderbolt. [I think it might be the top of a Roman standard (battle flag) - at least, I can't see a thunderbolt.] On the left side rises the prow of a galley, which terminates in the snarling mask of a lion. [The finished marble has three prows.]

To indicate the supremacy of Europe in civic matters, the sculptor has given her the crenellated crown of Cybele, mother of the gods of Greece. [I couldn't find a good discussion of the significance of this type of crown, so I didn't mention it in OMOM.] One clenched hand is on the big book, the other rests on the prow of the ancient galley. Europe gazes forward with uplifted chin, wearing a defiant look, as if ready to repel aggression. [There certainly was aggression building up: the Continents were dedicated in 1907, when European leaders were concocting the web of alliances that eventually engulfed Europe in World War I.] Asia: "Near the Whitehall corner will stand a throne bearing a woman in an Assyrian miter [a tall, pointed hat], with her eyes closed like a Buddha and a little effigy of Buddha in her lap.

The right hand holds the stalk of a lotus [hmm, no mention of the snake: I wonder if it was a late addition, or just difficult to see? It's visible above at the far right of the lotus stem], the left is laid palm downward on her knee. The footstool before the throne rests on skulls. A nude Asiatic to the right lays his forehead on the ground, and by her side marches an attenuated figure like an Indian fakir, with trembling limbs and head bowed down, followed closely by a woman with closed eyes.

The bosom of the symbolized Asia is covered with strings of jewels. To the left, with back turned and head fawning near her shoulder, sits a big tiger, while directly behind her back is a cross with rays." And finally, Africa: "If Asia sits erect, her eyes closed in ecstatic meditation, Africa seems to slumber as she sits with left elbow on the head of her lion, right elbow on a reduction of the famous Sphinx. The features are somewhat thick, the lips and chin suggest the negro, but the nose is bent, the hair is long, and it is continued in a big plait to the waist. Behind and near the Sphinx is a figure entirely covered with drapery save for the toes of one foot and the eyes under the shadow of the cloak, representing, perhaps, the mystery of the Dark Continent.

The hands of this figure [I think he's talking about Africa again] are loose and slightly incurved, so as to accentuate the idea of sleep, which is already marked by drooping head and closed eyes. Thus we have Europe and America with eyes open and alertness in the features; but Asia and Africa either brooding on religious themes or fast asleep."

 New York Times 1/14/1906: "World's Greatest Customs House Will Soon be Completed." The reporter describes Asia as "the personification of a mysticism that slumbers through countless centuries, regardless of the sufferings of the ignorant multitudes crouched at her knees. … behind her appears the approaching cross and sun of a conquering religion." Africa "is seated between the lion and the sphinx, a veiled figure of mystery at her back, an expression of hopelessness and world-weariness in her bowed head." [I think she's sound asleep, not depressed.]

 Europe "offers a fine contrast to the two typifying the darker and older continents. Crowned and seated on a throne covered with emblems of past achievements, one hand rests on the mighty book of the past, the other is clasped above the prow of a vessel, while the eyes look calmly forward to the future." America "is portrayed as  a youthful woman of rare beauty seated on a stone covered with barbaric inscriptions. The pose of the head, the forward movement of the body, are full of energy and hopeful expectancy. A lighted torch is in one hand, sheaves of corn rest upon the knees. With arms folded on a rock at her back, an Indian in all the panoply of primitive splendor peers over her shoulder.

At her side and under the protecting folds of her mantle kneels a half-nude masculine figure, strong and reliant, with the implements of industry in his hands, denoting labor."

 In a letter of 8/24/1916 to Grant M. Overton, Cass Gilbert, the architect of the Customs House who specified the theme of the four ground-level facade sculptures, gave a detailed description of the symbolism of the Continents (excerpted in Bogart, Public Sculpture and the Civic Ideal, pp. 130-33). Asia, he said, is "calm and serene in itself … costume obviously oriental, the face impassive, the throne resting upon the skulls of dead humanity . … To the right the tiger, beast of the jungle significant of the power of evil, seeking its prey by night, furtive yet powerful, freer than humanity itself, but subordinated also to the calm cynical intellectual power of the central figure, looks questioningly up into the face of Asia. In the lap of the central figure is the idol, symbol of false worship, while above the right shoulder of the figure is seen the rising luminous cross of Christianity, symbol of hope, which found its birth place on the continent of Asia."  Gilbert also notes the "toiling prostrate figures representing the masses of humanity borne down by superstition, tyranny and oppression." Europe is "enthroned upon a seat of classic design … She rests her right arm upon a bound volume of laws supported by the globe, over which her modern system of law and civilization has spread. At her right are the prows of the ships of the adventurous Norse discoverers. Rising behind the figure is the Roman Eagle, symbol of empire. Upon the border of her robe are embroidered arms armorial (symbols of sovereignty) of the great dominating nations of the old world." He also describes Europe as "an Imperial figure of the highest intelligence .. high civilization, great luxury, intellectuality and power." America holds a torch of progress, and is a "beautiful, alert, young female figure, rising to meet new conditions of civilization, eager for advancement in all that makes for peace and happiness." She throws back her cape "as though eager to cast aside whatever might impede her upward and forward movement." Beside her is "a kneeling male figure, setting in motion the winged wheel of commerce; while in the background, seen over her right shoulder, is the figure of an American Indian.

The bundle of fagots in her lap may perhaps represent the bundling together of the races or of the states that individually would be weak but collectively are strong. [What Gilbert calls a bundle of fagots - kindling - is in fact the bottom of a sheaf of corn, clearly visible from the left side.] America is young, vital, forceful and beautiful. The future is her own." Africa is "somnolent in every line of her figure. Her right arm rests upon the head of the silent sphinx, remnant of the art of by-gone time," but "some day perhaps to awake with all the power of brute force. … Behind her is a heavily draped and cowled figure, mystical, veiled, contemplative and impenetrable."

 Adams, Adeline. Daniel Chester French, Sculptor (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1932), especially pp. 51-53. Europe is “unshaken in her maritime pride, sits nobly amid her ancient glories of art, letters, science, discovery; her history, represented by a powerful Sybilline form, is by no means relegated to oblivion, but remains on call, a venerable counselor.” [That's a new take.] Asia, "mother of religions, is rapt in contemplation; she holds a lotus scepter in her hand, a figure of Buddha in her lap; behind her, unnoted by her, is the radiant Christian cross. A great tiger is on her right, his powerful lines binding the group together; at her left are suffering men and women; beneath her feet is a footstool resting on skulls.” Africa is “Less complicated . . . not yet awakened from a dream in which both the lion and sphinx appear.” [A dream?!] “In full contrast with all of these is America, the alert continent, looking up, not down, thinking forward, not backward; at her side a strong youth turns his winged wheel. Her eagle is near, her Indian remains behind, her footstool bears symbols of the ancient Aztec civilization.”

 Cresson, Margaret French [French's daughter]. The Life of Daniel Chester French: Journey into Fame  (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1947), especially pp. 211-12. Europe: “She is a proud and royal sovereign, sitting erectly with a crown on her imperious head and a look of conscious power. She is seated on a throne that bears reliefs from the Parthenon frieze while over her shoulder press the prows of three ships laden with the commerce of her rich harbors, for Europe is the Conqueror of the Seas. She was such a rich continent, Dan had debated doing her as an old woman loaded with jewels, but the stately figure of the younger woman wouldn’t let him go, and he found her coming to life under his hands.” “The group of ‘Africa’ was the other end of the pendulum, a heavy seated fig of a woman, sleeping, one arm thrown over the mane of a recumbent lion, the other resting on the head of the Sphinx. The suggestion of age and decay was emphasized by a shrouded figure at the back of the group, which indicated the mystery of the desert and the impenetrable jungles of the Dark Continent. … It had a big quality, a more sculpturesque quality than most of his things, and he [French] discovered that he had gone on to greater heights and struck a newer note.” Asia: “Where the ‘Africa’ was all physical, though unawakened, emotion, the ‘Asia’ was all spirituality and aloofness. She sits upright, with formality. Her face, with eyelids closed, wears an expression of serenity, introspection, and unhurried calm. Her clothes are the formalized and flowing garments of the East. The feet rest upon a footstool of the skulls of men to illustrate the legend of Buddha, who, on being shown a skull found on a neighboring hill, said, ‘All Asia is built on skulls, the bones of the reincarnate.’ [Now there's an explanation we haven't heard before!] While in the background, unseen by her, remains the Cross of Christ. It was a group that was replete with narrative, experience, and tradition and only an artist could appreciate the knowledge and study involved, the patient labor and the mental strain necessary to conceive, to compose, and to carry through to completion a group of this scale with such a wealth and variety of appropriate detail, the accessories kept always in scholarly unity.” America: “She is young and strong, alert and alive in every fiber of her being. She sits erect, leaning forward slightly in her eagerness, her uplifted eyes seeing the vision of the future. Her arm is shielding a figure of Progress, who kneels at her side, setting in motion his winged wheel to denote inventive genius. She is seated upon a block of stone decorated with Aztec symbols, and her foot rests on the symbolic feathered serpent of Mexico. Over her shoulder peers an American Indian in his war bonnet, a romantic and tragic reminder of one of the darkest stains on our fabulous history. The whole group of ‘America’ is eager and ardent, vital and vigorous, an interesting contrast to the more reposeful qualities of the other three.”

 Lederer, Joseph. All Around the Town: A Walking Guide to Outdoor Sculpture in New York City (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1975), pp. 15-16. Asia: "this hieratic figure is the most formalized, iconlike of all. In her lap is a small Buddhist figure, beneath her feet a cluster of skulls. Her right hand holds a lotus flower with a serpent coiled around its stem. [Ah, somebody else did see the snake!] A prostrate youth joins his elders in worshiping this mother of religion." America: "Gazing forward, urgently alive to the future, this figure - the most ardent - holds the torch of liberty in her right hand and protects the embodiment of enterprising manhood with her left. Without a suggestion of irony or the faintest sense of contradiction, America is shown subjugating the serpent-headed Quetzalcoatl under foot while, in the background, a North American Indian peers over her shoulder." Europe: "enthroned and crowned; behind her the hooded figure of History holds a book and a human skull wreathed with laurel. Erect and alert, Europe is surrounded by symbols (such as a frieze from the Parthenon) largely of the past." Africa: "shown in deep slumber. Behind this seminude Nubian queen looms a shrouded figure, representing, perhaps, the unknown future of the dark continent."

 Richman, Michael. Daniel Chester French, An American Sculptor (Preservation Press, Landmark Reprint Series, 1976), pp. 103-111, with photos of early maquettes, clay models, and the finished Continents, and quotes from French's correspondence. French noted of Asia that the figures at the side represent "the hordes of India, and the hopelessness of the life of so many of the inhabitants" (letter of 2/26/1929). The sheaf of corn on America's lap signifies "the American idea of Plenty" (letter by French of 8/31/1916). Behind Europe is a figure who "reads a scroll and holds in her hand a laurel-crowned skull. At her feet are crowns, - of her dead kings?" (letter by French of 8/31/1916).

Gayle, Margot, and Michele Cohen. The Art Commission and the Municipal Art Society Guide to Manhattan's Outdoor Sculpture (New York: Prentice Hall, 1988), pp. 12-13. Asia: represented as the "mother of religion," "a Buddha-like figure absorbed in a meditative trance. She holds a sacred lotus flower with a serpent wrapped around the stem ... a statuette of a Buddha rests on her lap ... The sculptor contrasts the figure's composure and voluptuous forms with the emaciated body of the man bent forward in supplication and the prostrate youth at her feet. French implies that spiritual salvation, as defined by Buddhist philosophy, falls short of human sustenance." [A bit too broad a generalization, that.] Africa: "veiled in the mysteries of sleep and darkness ... Massive, slumbering, and semi-nude, Africa rests one arm on a sphinx, evoking ancient Egypt, and the other on a lion, typically associated with the 'dark continent.' [Yes, but the association with sheer physical power is stronger than the association with a continent.] The personification of Africa suggests that French and his public perceived the continent as a passive land, characterized by untapped resources and unawakened potential." America: the authors note that critics of the time interpreted this as the ideal woman of the New World, "associating her with America's pioneer women and colonial settlers. In her right hand she holds a torch, symbolic of liberty and enlightenment, while an abundant sheaf, representing material prosperity, balances across her lap. A robust figure of Labor turns the wheel of progress, a straightforward reference to America's growing industrial power at the beginning of the 20th century. As America looks to the future, an Indian crouching behind her right shoulder is a reminder of her past and by his position implies a tacit acceptance of the 'march of progress'." Europe: "the regal continent and disseminator of knowledge ...The Parthenon frieze carved on the throne and her Grecian garb evoke Classical Greece and the imperial eagle over her right shoulder recalls ancient Rome. Behind Europe is Ancient History, depicted as an old woman holding a laurel-covered skull reading a scroll."

 Bogart, Michele H. Public Sculpture and the Civic Ideal in New York City, 1890-1930 (University of Chicago Press, 1989). Chapter 6 is on the Customs House, with many interesting archival photos of models and bureaucratic details on the process by which the sculptures were produced. Augustus Saint Gaudens was invited to produce the four sculptures for the base of the façade, but that he promptly refused with the comment that "The United States are not pleasant people to have dealings of that kind with," and that the price was "not what I receive for my work and I am not rich enough to indulge in the execution of work no matter how alluring when there is other at hand much more lucrative" (p. 118). Bogart comments, "For Saint-Gaudens, who had done so much to champion the cause of a national art, the desire for artistic perfection and the federal bureaucracy's insistence on punctuality seemed to have become irreconcilable." (On Saint Gaudens's design for the double eagle gold coin, see Outdoor Monuments of Manhattan Essay 42, Theodore Roosevelt.)

 SIRIS (Smithsonian Institution, Inventory of American Sculpture) IAS 87870014 (Africa), 87870015 (Asia), 87870016 (America), 76009558 (Europe).

 See also Doug Yeo's page on Daniel Chester French for excellent photos and comments on the Continents. He notes that Africa was commonly referred to as the "sleeping continent," and was just beginning to awaken in the early 20th c. He also quotes critic Charles De Kay as saying that the shrouded figure behind Africa "expresses the mystery of the deserts and the unexplored recesses of Africa's primeval forests." (De Kay was the art critic for the New York Times in the early 20th c.; this is from an article in Century Magazine, 1906, quoted by Richman, p. 109.) Re Asia, Yeo states that the cross represents the beginning of Christian missionary effort in Asia. [A bit late, surely?] He identifies the shrouded figure next to Europe as Ancient History. For America, Yeo identifies the "footstool" as the head of Quetzalcoatl, the Toltecs' plumed serpent who represented the forces of light, good, and civilization. [I haven't seen any representation of Quetzalcoatl whose resemblance to the footstool was striking, so I didn't include that comment in OMOM; but the footstool does look like Aztec carvings, so I did mention that.] Yeo says that the side of America's throne is covered with Mayan glyphs, which seemed to be confirmed by comparison with images on the Web. (Any Mayan glyph scholars out there? I wonder if these are just decoration, or if they have a meaning.)

 

On the sculptor, Daniel Chester French

American National Biography: Philip H. Viles, Jr. "French, Daniel Chester"; http://www.anb.org/articles/17/17-00301.html ; American National Biography Online Feb. 2000.

Adams, Adeline. Daniel Chester French, Sculptor (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1932).

Cresson, Margaret French. The Life of Daniel Chester French: Journey into Fame  (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1947). Cresson was French's daughter, and she recounts some anecdotes about French that would otherwise have been lost. For instance, she notes that French was good at handling committees. They often thought they wanted a portrait statue, but French would do a sketch for a portrait and also a draped angel, and the committee would decide it was the angel they had wanted all along. His wife Mary couldn’t understand how he did that: “Even when people admit they don’t know much about art, they all insist they know what they like.” “But they don’t know what they like,” commented Dan. “Very few people do. They have to be educated up to it. When they’ve studied a little and seen a good deal, and listened and thought, then they may achieve a considered opinion, but certainly not before. … I never talk them down,” said Dan. “I know enough not to try. I simply suggest to them a better solution of their problem, and they usually have the wit to see it.”

 Richman, Michael. Daniel Chester French, An American Sculptor (Preservation Press, Landmark Reprint Series, 1976).

On the U.S. Customs House at Bowling Green

New York Times 1/14/1906: "World's Greatest Customs House Will Soon be Completed." "Recent years have been remarkable for the erection of great, monumental buildings in New York [built recently or under construction ca. 1906: the Flatiron Building, Metropolitan Life Building at Madison Square, New York Times Building at Times Square], and this to such an extent that the city may be said to have entered upon an era of architecture that aims to harmonize the utmost demands of utility with an aesthetic beauty and appropriateness of design that enhances the value of the total effect, an aim that was not always in evidence in buildings of an older date. … It is the unity of idea embodied in the new Custom House and enforced by the wealth of sculpture with which it is embellished, more than its mere costliness, that gives to the edifice its unique value. So thoroughly has this unity been observed, and so plainly is its meaning hewn in unlettered language into broad shapes of stone, that to every stranger entering the city the exterior of the building announces the presence of a great Temple of Commerce, the meeting place of all the nations to do business with the New World. … A series of forty-four Corinthian columns surround the building. These columns, forming an important architectural feature of the whole, are crowned by composite capitals, from whose fern-like decorations the head of Hermes, God of Commerce [as on Grand Central's façade, OMOM Essay 26], looks out. … Over each window, and running around the entire building, heads are carved to represent the eight types of mankind, the head of a woman forming the keystone to the arch over the main entrance. …

 [The cornice] consists of twelve heroic figures, each about 11 feet in height and weighing twenty tons, representing famous seafaring powers, ancient and modern …Above these twelve figures is a group representative of the United States - two winged female figures holding between them the American shield with eagle above and horns of plenty below - by Karl Bitter."

The reporter concludes by noting that most critics have praised the Custom House, except a female writer in Boston's The Transcript, who said: "There is much that is beautiful, much that is admirable, in this building. But it is restless. The pillars are not bound into a monumental brotherhood - they lack a strong, inter-fraternal, basic attachment. … They stand side by side, it is true, in admirable symmetry, but there is lacking an absolutely unifying esprit de corps." Our man from the Times comments, "It is frequently difficult to translate Bostonese. From the above one gathers that there is a transcendental something the matter with the new Custom House, although the building is at the same time thoroughly admirable and symmetrical - a consolatory kind of criticism that leaves one in a good humor and at the same time in a state of perplexity, 'restless,' as the building itself is said to be by this profound critic." ["A consolatory kind of criticism": I wish I'd thought of that line!]

 New York Times, 5/13/1906: "Spain and Venice Figured. Cass Gilbert Talks of the Statues for His Custom House on Bowling Green." The reporter asks Gilbert why the sculptures aren't bronze (Gilbert says the bronze would have stood out too sharply from the building) and also whether in general Gilbert favors sculpture as an adjunct to architecture. Gilbert replies, "For monumental buildings I regard it [as] practically essential to the full expression of the design. It gives light and shade in a more or less informal way, which cannot be done by ordinary architectural forms. Indeed, I use sculpture where I cannot employ pilasters, vases, or other conventional forms." The reporter comments that sculptors won't like the way Gilbert phrased that. "'Oh,' said Mr. Gilbert, laughing, 'the sculptors can take care of themselves. They have plenty of avenues of expression outside of architecture. I'm only considering one small part of sculpture - its intimate relation to architecture.'"

 Bogart, Michele H. Public Sculpture and the Civic Ideal, p. 129, notes that in the group by Karl Bitter symbolizing the United States (at the top center of the Customs House), one figure has a sheathed sword symbolizing the nation at peace, and the other has the fasces, symbolizing force and strength. (On the fasces, see OMOM Essay 6, Washington.) She also states that the head over the central arch is Mercury (Hermes), god of commerce, rather than Columbia (see photo above).

 "Report to the Landmarks Preservation Commission," 1/9/1979, designation list 122, LP-1022, Landmarks Preservation Commission, New York.

 Historic Structure Report: Old Custom House, New York, New York. Prepared for Marcel Breure Associates, James Stewart Polshek & Partners, Goldman-Sokolow-Copeland, A Joint Venture - Architects / Engineers, by The Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities, 1982 (typescript at New-York Historical Society).

 

Questions for thought and discussion

1. Look at French's models for the Continents in plaster and clay. (Richman has photos.) Find two elements on each that appear only in the finished marble. What do those elements add to the meaning of the figures? If they had not been included, would it have changed the message or the emphasis of that particular Continent?

 2. Pick one feature and study it across all four figures: e.g. eyes, hands, hairstyle, costume, footrest. How does this one element help distinguish the figures?

 3. Visually, what similarities tie these four figures together? Consider composition (the arrangement of objects), massing (the shape of the groups from a distance) and repetition of figures, objects or shapes.

4. Read contemporary and later descriptions of one of the Continents, and observe changes in the type of comments, in particular what's acceptable to mention and what phrases are acceptable for describing it.

  

Bonus

  • At the dedication of Daniel Chester French's Lincoln for the Lincoln Memorial, President Harding quoted Lincoln as saying:

If I were trying to read, much less answer, all the attacks made on me, this shop might as well be closed for any other business. I do the best I know how, the very best I can; and I mean to keep on doing it to the end. If the end brings me out all right, that which is said against me will not amount to anything. If the end brings me out all wrong, ten angels swearing I was right would make no difference.

  • In Outdoor Monuments and on my blog, I discussed the winged wheel pushed by the man next to America. The penditives supporting the ceiling in Grand Central's Main Concourse have more of these winged wheels - unfortunately I haven't taken photos with my super-zoom camera yet. Another pair of these wheels hold up the awning on the south side of what used to be the headquarters of the New York Central Railroad, on 48th St. facing the northern exit of Grand Central Terminal and the Pan Am building. I think these are actually railroad wheels!

 

 

click here

New York sculpture - Essays -  Gifts, greetings & recommended readings
About this site
- Contact - Site updates - Site map

  Comments, queries, corrections and suggestions: comments@forgottendelights.com.
Unless otherwise noted, all photographs on this site are (c) Dianne Durante
and may not be reproduced
without written permission.